[By Jane Ashworth and Michele Carlisle During this…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-12-04Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
By Jane Ashworth and Michele Carlisle
During this year there has been an unfortunate and alarming growth of the politics of the hierarchy of oppression. It runs. something like this: 'How dare you disagree with me. I am a woman. If you disagree with me you are either a sexist, or not a real woman — you are a member of a male dominated organisation."
Another example might be: 'Not only did you disagree with a woman, you also shouted at her, by this type of logic you are not only a sexist but a sexual harasser. Never mind that if a woman did exactly the same, the incident would be understood as a row, if a man does it it is sexual harassment. (see footnote).
Fortunately this method of political argument - if you can call it that — is still confined to a few HE colleges. But it might spread, -S'SIN SSiN calls this type of logic stealing of feminism and abusing it for personal career advancement -just as bureaucrats use rule books and procedural points as an excuse for doing nothing.
There is no doubt that some women cry "sexist' when politically challenged, and even claim they don't have to answer - after all they are the true women's activists. And as women's activists they know not only the collective, subjective experience of all women, but have the sole franchise on interpreting this experience.
They are the pure feminists, they claim, they are unfettered by left wing (or any other ideology). They have distilled an objective truth which cannot be challenged, because every one else's view of the world is "male?.
So basically, it's bad luck if you fall foul of a femocrat. Objective arguments don't matter, facts don't matter much either. It is impossible to win. The rules of their game forbid honest debate.
Oddly enough femocrats only attack the left. Ruining someone's reputation with an accusation of harrasment is fair game. Never mind if it's not true, never mind finding our the facts, never mind a fair femocratic cliques want to victimise someone they will.
And if your enemy is a woman and so isn't going to be labelled a sexist too easily, then throw in another accusation, like homophobe or antisemite.
Not only do femocrats deny that there is a real world that can be argued over and analysed by scientific objective methods. They are denying much that is progressive in our society like natural justice and a recognition of the value of objectivity over subjectivity. Denying others the right to argue leads to verbal vigilante groups who feel free from any constraints. They can assert and slander and no-one has the right to object.
That is rather a large problem, because if the logic is carried through properly it would put femocrats back time to before the Greek philosophers who worked out that there are objective facts.
But there are also more problems with femocracy. Femocrats cheapen the very struggles that they claim to be promoting. There are real issues at stake like sexism, anti-semitism, antilesbian and gay prejudice, anti-black racism. Femocrats will not try to conI Michele Carlisle vince people and build campaigns. Infact they function as *thought police'. • They patrol activists' minds looking for al slip, not to try to explain why someone is wrong to say, for example, chairman but to denounce them for it, to score points, to 'prove' that someone is a sexist. Femocracy is also politically introverted Why bother to go out and fight for working class socialism, when the problem is all these members of op pressing groups, particularly men?
For the femocrats it's all a matter of listing a hierachy of oppression, and the ruling class (when it gets attention at all is just one more power group. It's all a matter of groups in society, who oppress in varying degrees and should be forced to 'give up their power?, This is wrong. It is true that various strata in society have privileges but the fundamental power relationship is between the bourgeoisie and the working class.
The power that a working-class man has over a working-class woman is absolutely negligable when compared to the murdering, decadent, crushing power of the international ruling class.
Within that relationship of ruling class and working class, all women are oppressed and working-class women are doubly oppressed - as workers and as women. The key to women's liberation is the class struggle. Only with the creation of a socievices' to suit everyone;which is free from the reactionary ideology which divides the working class, by giving some workers privileges over others - like men's power over women; only in such a society will women be truly liberated.
The root of women's oppression lies in the structure of society. While women are trained and chanelled into a life of domestic drudgery; while other avenues are closed off, while the ruling class relies on a woman's unpaid labour to service its male workers and rear the next generation of factory and cannon fodder. Then women will be oppressed. Only in a socialist society when the necessary resources can be put into communalising domestic labour, where women are treated as individuals and not as just potential wives, mothers and sex objects. Only then will there be the material base for women's liberation.
Yes, we want a movement which fights for everyone, not just for white straight men.
Yes, we want a movement that fights sexism and racism.