Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

"reducing unemployment". In fact unemployed and reducing the

Socialist Organiser no. 295, 4 December 1986 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 2,647 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

it is a way of terrorising the

unemployment statistics. anyone unemployed for six months or more.

Interviews

The Restart interviews are carried out in Job Centres by speciallytrained Restart teams. Failure on the part of the claimant to attend the interview results - after two invitations' to attend - in the claimant having his or her benefit cut off.

At the interview the claimant is 'offered' a variety of 'options'. Rather than run the risk of being deemed 'unavailable for work' for rejecting all 'options' , many claimants unwill ingly accept one of them:

•Community Programme: At present pays an average of f65 per week for a full-time post; but most posts are part-time. •Enterprise Allowance Scheme: A scheme whereby the government pays you t40 a week to set yourself up in business; applies only to unemployed with access to f1,000 of their own; the scheme's major drawback is the proneness of businesses set up under it to go bankrupt.

•Training courses: The staple answer of the MSC and the Tories to unemployment; but being re-trained does not necessarily lead to being reemployed.

Voluntary

•Voluntary Work: Unwaged work, especially liked by the Tories due to its role in destroying existing jobs and dragging down rates of pay.

•Jobstart: A top-up temporary allowance paid out where the unemployed take up a job paying less than £80 a week.

•Jobclubs: Provision by Job Centres of special facilities (i.e. telephone and typewriter) for the unemployed to help them find work; claimants enjoying the use of such facilities are expected to make at least ten job applications per day, four days a week.

•Restart Counselling Courses: Particularly useless week-long courses in which claimants are lectured on the problems of being unemployed and taught that they are themselves to blame for being unemployed, by not seeking work energetically enough.

•A Job: A particularly scarce item, received by only 1% of those called for a Restart interview.

of Restart as a nationwide scheme.

Preliminary results from the first two weeks of the national programme reveal that just 166 out of the 7,469 claimants interviewed were placed into jobs — including Community Programme. This is an even worse result than in the pilot areas: 2.2% as against 5.7%.

Claims by Tory ministers and their civil servants that Restart has enjoyed a success rate of 91% should therefore be treated with the contempt they deserve: by basing its figures on the number of "positive offers of some kind" made during a Restart interview rather than on the number of filled places or jobs, the Department of Employment has exaggerated the 'success' of Restart by up to twenty times.

Nonsense

One of the more senior officials in the MSC has even gone so tar as to describe, in private, the grossly inflated claims of Employment Minister Kenneth Clarke about the success of Restart as "absolute nonsense". Not that any of this has stopped Tory ministers persisting in their outlandish claims about the "success' of Restart.

Clearly, Restart is not a genuine attempt to make inroads into the problem of mass long-term unemployment. What, then, lies behind Restart?

Firstly, Restart is the government's attempt in the run-up to a General Election, to sway the electorate into believing that it is 'doing something' about long-term unemploymentwhich it itself has helped create.

Hence the vast amounts of money which the Tories are prepared to plough into Restart. Some £5.4 million has been invested in various media-hypes in order to provide Restart with a high public profile — and in sharp contrast to the Tories* arguments that there is 'no money in the kitty' to support even an extremely modest special employment creation scheme.

Hence also the insistence of Tory politicians as to the 'success' of Restart, despite the mass of evidence to the contrary. MSC-supremo Lord Young, for example, has argued that the small increase in the unemployment figures for August was due to Restart, whilst Kenneth Clarke told a away like snow" when called for a Restart interview. But why should all the facts to the contrary be considered when the goal is to con people into believing that the Tories are trying to cut unemployment?

Further evidence that Restart is, in part, a pre-election gimmick is to be found in the pattern of Department of Employment staffing for the Restart programme: of the eight staff working centrally on the programme (the majority of staff are employed by the MSC), two work in the Manpower Policy Division whilst six are Information Officers in the Department's Publicity and Promotions Unit.

Thus, the Tories cynically distort the reality of Restart with the deliberate intention of duping the electorate, especially those with a job and who might therefore be less concerned with the problems of mass unemployment. The unemployed themselves who are forced to go through the charade of Restart will not be so easily duped - but the Tories equally cynically recognise that only a low percentage of the unemployed bother to vote..

The second goal of Restart, following on from the above, is to divert attention away from the real causes of unemployment. Restart is underpinned by the notion that the unemployed themselves are to blame for unemployment, not the Tories' economic and political policies or the workings of the capitalist system.

Adverts Thus, for example, one of the television adverts for Restart shows a large stock of capacity - actory plant, computers, construction sites - lurking behind Job Centre doors, just waiting to employ the long-term unemployed. The impression thereby created that unemployment is not due to jobscarcity but to a lack of motivation and drive on the part of the unemployed.

The blame-the-unemployed-forbeing-unemployed syndrome is even more apparent in the week-long Restart 'counselling' course, one of the 'options' on offer at a Restart interview. The course does not offer a job but engages in fairly low-level social engineering. As the manual for the course tutors puts it: "It is hoped

Scan page 7

iria Riley with their four children, Maria (7), dole for 11 years and in that time has had only work behind a bar in the last ten years. The i offer them nothing. Photo: John Harris, IFL.

'RESTART' - THE SUCCESS STORY OF THE Place Number of letters sent How many got Billingham 941 4 Preston 3,130 9 Huddersfield 2,554 15 Stoke 4,140 23 Port Talbot 2,615 53 Plymouth 2,537 7 Crawley 643 53 Ealing 2,260 38 Dundee 3,919 11 Breakdown of pilot scheme placements - taken from: that those hardest hit by unemployment see this course as a very first step in becoming competitive in the labour market" and therefore the task of the course is to "help participants move from a reactive stance to unemployment ('waiting for something to happen') towards a more pro-active approach, which encompasses a belief that it is possible to exercise some control over what is happening to them.

Consoles

The course manual does, however, admit that "we must not hide from the fact that some course members Will remain unemployed, possibly for a substantial time" but consoles itself with the thought that "the extent to which this course can help them better cope with unemployment will in itself be a valuable outcome"

From the point of view of the tutor's manual, therefore, unemployment is reduced to a set of personal problems, to be dealt with by lowering claimants' expectations as to what constitutes a reasonable rate of pay, by teaching them thrift, and by raising their motivation through a variety of ridiculous role-playing exercises.

What needs to be stressed is not how ridiculous such adverts or courses are, but the logic, for want of a better word, upon which they are based: since jobs are supposedly available for the asking, the eradication of unemployment merely involves motivating the unemployed to ask for them. Unemployment, therefore, is not the Tories' fault but the fault of the unemployed themselves.

A third goal of Restart is to cut the unemployment figures (which should not be confused with cutting unemployment). The two means whereby Restart achieves this are: encouraging claimants to de-register (or disqualifying claimants from registering); and 'encouraging' claimants to go on a fake 'job-creation' scheme.

Failure to attend a Restart interview, as pointed out above, leads to a suspension of benefits, on the basis of the assumption that nonattendance equals non-availability for work: the claimant is removed from the register. Although, at present, explicit compulsion relates only to attendance at an interview, this is not the only instrument with which claimants can be struck off the register.

The Restart interview itself represents a means for policing a more stringent criteria.

Officials are now empowered to make subjective judgements on the basis of such criteria as whether or not the claimant is imposing restrictions on the hours which she or he is prepared to work, gr whether or not she or he is "unreasonably" refusing a particular type of job.

As a Daily Telegraph article, based on a Department of Employment briefing, put it: "Special teams trained to detect false claimants for unemployment benefits have made many (claimants) have second thoughts (about claiming benefit)"

Compulsion

Moreover, although Restart is on record as being strictly voluntary, claimants, in practice, inevitably feel pressurised into taking up one of the 'options' on offer. Claimants are not unjustified in their suspicion that rejection of an option can lead to a cutoff of benefit:

•Restart officials are charged with recording the reaction of claimants to the options on a response sheet -but there is no facility made on this sheet to allow for claimants rejecting all eight options.

•The last Labour government's Social Security Act of 1975 allows for claimants to be disqualified from benefit if they ignore any "official recommendation given with a view to assisting him (sic) to find suitable employment" or if they ignore an opportunity of approved training "for the purpose of becoming or keeping fit for entry into, or return to, regular employment"

The wording of the 1975 legislation is obviously so lax that it amounts to a blank cheque for the Tories and the MSC. At present though, the Tories are having the best of both worlds. They have not stated that a refusal of all options leads to disqualification from benefits, (which could create a dangerous electoral backlash). But neither have they openly stated that claimants are free to reject all options, thus leaving the threat of disqualification hanging over every Restart interview. And how many claimants are going to call the Tories bluff by rejecting all the options when their sole source of income is at stake? As the Tories know full well not many.

The second way in which Restart helps doctor the unemployment figures is through channelling claimants onto Tory fake 'jobcreation' schemes, under the threat of loss of benefit dealt with in the preceding paragraphs. Restart thus fits into the much broader Thatcherite project of restructuring the labour market at the expense of workers, by cutting wages, weakening trade unionism, and undermining free collective bargaining.

Two of the options offered at a Restart interview particularly contribute towards this goal: Job Start (a £20 weekly allowance paid out for a year where a job pays less than €80 a week) and the Community Programme (in which the predominantly part-time rates of pay amount to little more than what would be otherwise paid out in unemployment benefit).

Restart, therefore, is not to be supported under any circumstances: it is geared to promote the creation of a low-waged, marginalised (and even conscripted) labour market. It does not even pretend to take a serious stance on employment creation, but instead, enables more stringent management of the unemployed, in which further doctoring of the figures plays an ever stronger role.

DECADE?

Interviewed:

Placed in jobs:

Community Programme:

Jobclubs:

Enterprise Allowance Scheme:

Training Courses:

Restart Courses:

Voluntary Projects Programme:

'Unemployment Bulletin' issue 21. lan McCalman takes a look at Labour's plans education.

The current issue of Socialism and Education', journal of the Socialist Education Association (SEA) is devoted to discussing a future Labour government's programme for education.

One of the key issues highlighted is the future of the fee-paying sector. Although less than 10% of the school population attend such schools (the figure in Scotland is less than 5%), the role of the "private" sector is significant and growing.

Its significance lies not only in that it makes education a privilege rather than a right. It also resides in the way in which the tee-paying sector serves as a bulwark of the class divided society we live in.

Of those who are educated in this way, an even smaller percentage attend the exclusive 'public' schools such as Eton, Harrow and Winchester. But their importance lies not in these numerical terms but in the manner in which they serve as training grounds for those who staff the ruling elites in our society, in the civil service, the military, the judiciary, etc.

Educated

The fee-paying sector has certainly been growing in recent years. The run-down of the state sector by the Tory government and the attendant conflicts with teachers' unions over salaries, conditions and resources have persuaded growing numbers of middle class parents to opt for the "private' sector. In this they have received encouragement in the form of subsidies from the government out by Restart staff a job 28,175 100% 295 1.0% 1,310 4.6% 273 1.0% 72 0.3% 262 1.0% 2,114 7.5% 84 0.3% through the Assisted Places Scheme.

A starting point for a programme to tackle these issues must be the SEA resolution passed at this year's Labour Party conference. This states the need for the drafting of a 1988 Education Act prior to the next eleccalls voich, heong other demands, end of subsidy to 'public' schools including the end of charity status, the assisted places scheme and the dismantling of the 'public' school system in this country beginning with the prevention of institutions charging fees to provide education in the statutory sector".

Obviously a resolution by its very nature must be cryptic but this seems to be condensed to the point of confusion.

There can be no dubiety concerning the ending of charges in the state sector (many Labour authorities have recently sharply increased fees for evening classes) and the abolition of the Assisted Places Scheme.

Why the resolution should reserve its fire for the 'public' schools rather than the whole fee-paying sector, however, is unclear. Tax concessions, including charity status, must be ended for all fee-paying schools. This must be part of a programme to integrate those schools into the state sector.

How that is to be done is a more complicated issue. Caroline Benn, in an article in the current issue of Socialism and Education, writes of developing the private sector to serve the needs of the whole community". It would be interesting to know what kind of proposals she has in mind. The danger is that it may contain the seeds of growth rather than decline of the fee-paying sector.

The argument of the right is, as always, that such moves are a denial of freedom. Socialists have to counter this with the view that within the context of an unequal society, fee-paying in education, as in health, is a privilege aimed at creating greater inequalities.

This does not mean that socialists. should be insensitive to the issue of freedom within the state sector. We should positively support moves to break up the present, monolithic, institutionalised, bureaucatic system of state schools. We should study the Scandinavian experience of parents and teachers being encouraged to set up small scale, experimental schools within the state sector. The ossified structures which exist at present hopefully in no way prefigure the kind of society socialists strive to create.

----- pull-quotes -----

claimant's "availability for work" on the basis of recently introduced

Life in Thatcher's Britain

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 295

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →