Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Paying the price of racism

Socialist Organiser no. 295, 4 December 1986 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 2,132 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Paris became home for many black jazz musicians in the '50s and '60s, seeking to escape the racism, rip-offs and lack of recognition for their music in the US.

*Round Midnight' is the story of the relationship between Dale Turner, a tenor saxophonist, who comes to Paris and Francis, a French fan. It is loosely based on the true story of Bud Powell, the bebop pianist.

Turner is an alcoholic, ex-drug addict, who is locked in his room between gigs and not allowed the money he earns, so as to prevent him drinking it away. The only thing keeping him from destruction is his will to keep playing.

Turner is played by Dexter Gordon, himself one of the few survivors of the bop era of the '40s, who lived for 15 years in Europe. 6' 5" tall, with a slow voice like sandpaper and a convincing drunken lurch, Gordon's eyes show us that he's not just acting a part but reliving his own and his contemporaries lives. (All the Bruce Robinson went to see 'Around went to see Midnight'.

musicians parts are played by real musicians such as Herbie Hancock and Bobby Hutcherson. This not only means we see real players playing real music but adds their conviction to the film).

At first the relationship between Francis and Dale is that of an adoring fan who buys his idol drinks. Their common love of the music gradually creates a real human feeling between them as Francis becomes Dale's guardian and invites him to live in his flat and Dale begins to respond by taking up composition and soprano saxophone again.

Francis is not altogether sympathetic. Everyone else is sacrificed to his support for Dale. He is as much of an addict as Dale he begins to neglect his 11 year old daughter, to stand outside a night club in a thunderstorm listening, as he can't afford to go in. At the end of the film, Dale returns to New York from his exile to the "same old shit" of pushers, rip-off agents and rundown hotels and dies soon after.

The story alone doesn't do justice to the film. Its atmosphere and the music help explain why both fans and musicians become so absorbed in jazz. It's often both touching and funny.

By building on the stories and feelings of real musicians it undermines many patronising stereotypes - for example, Dale amazes Francıs by saying that his playing was influenced by the music of Debussy.

It shows the self-destructiveness of many jazz lives as not the price tor creativity, but as the price for living in a system where the contributions of black musicians were constantly downgraded If I'm enthusiastic, that may just be because I'm a jazz addict myself. If you aren't, this could film could get you hooked. from, ultimately, "socialism is the answer". This is a crass and inadequate response to the threat of intimidation and rape women face in their daily lives, Julie Waterson in Socialist Worker Review 88 sets out a "socialist answer" to rape. The 'problem' for her, does not in any sense he with male domination, supremacy Or privilege. Rather it is the result of the roles men and women are conditioned into: the idea that woman is there to have and to hold, to be used and abused by man; the idea that man is protector and guardian and seducer of woman; the idea that woman is chaste wife and mother, but also seductress and whore. We are to believe that these ideas/values are fundamental, they cause the divisions between men and women.

Undoubtely ideas about male and female roles help to perpetuate divisions between men and women. It is impossible to argue that pornography does not help to define male sexual fantasies and in some individual cases leads directly to sexual violence. But these ideas are rooted in the material privileges that all men, including working class men, have over women. These are the causes of the divisions.

For Waterson, "these ideas and the divisions they cause have to be seen in the framework of capitalist society" ...a society where... "the majority of people, both working class men and women suffer because of their alienation. Where being forced to depend on selling your labour power means having no real control over where you live, where you work or what you earn" . This causes misery and unhappiness and distorted sexual relationships. Men beaten up, the immediate "problem" is men. This is something feminists have understood for quite some time.

By railing against sexism in the here and now and then jumping into the future to conclude that tuture socialism is the answer, the SWP never get beyond moral outrage when discussing the question of rape now. This will not help women come to terms with their own feelings about their relationships with men, nor will it produce many "converts" to socialism.

There aren't any easy answers to violence against women. Socialism is ultimately the answer, but part of the fight for socialism has to be the taking on board of the demands and struggles of women. At no point does Waterson mention the self-organisation of women.

Self-organisation Women during the miners" strike organised themselves not only to support the strike, but also to tight back against the sexism on the picket lines, the sexism of their men. More thanthis: they began to see themselves as capable and strong individuals, equal to the men.

Women's self-organisation then is a key to fighting and removing sexist ideas. At the same time we must fight for better street lighting, minibus services, etc., which will help to combat the vulnerability of women. We must support the work of Rape Crisis Centres and Women's Aid.

Above all perhaps we need to debate violence against women in a much more thorough way and not take it up and drop it again when media interest die down - as the SWP do. 295.

Scan page 10

The leader of the Vietnamese struggle against the United States, until his death in 1969, was Ho Chi Minh. This article, translated from the French journal 'Chroniques Vietnamiennes' explains how H and the peasant-based Vietnamese Communist Party were responsible for the destruction of Vietnam's once powerful working class-basec Trotskyist movement. The article was translated by Richard Moore. In 1946, when Ho Chi Minh came to France to negotiate with the French government over the future status of Vietnam, the Trotskyists and their sympathisers questioned him on the death of Ta Thu Thau. Three discussions took place between Ho Chi Minh and our comrades.

The first discussion took place with Daniel Guerin, the historian and writer and in his youth a friend of Ta Thu Thau in the '30s. Daniel Guerin related the essential points of the discussion in his book 'In the Service of the colonised' in these terms:

*During his stay in Paris in 1946 l had a long discussion with Ho Chi Minh, but the pleasure experienced in hailing and celebrating with him the liberation of his country was overshadowed by not only ideological disagreements but also by the memory of Tau Thu Thau. Some over-zealous Stalinists around Ho Chi Minh had just, in effect, assassinated the former municipal councillor of Saigon for "Trotskyism' " He was a patriot and we cried for him,' Ho Chi Minh told me with sincere emotion but added immediately, "but all those who don' loe the line that I determine will be broken'* The second discussion took place with our comrade Rudolph Prager, a leading figure in the PCI (Parti Communiste Internationaliste the French section of the 4th International). A summary appeared in La Verite on 19 July 1946 under the heading 'Who killed Ta Thu Thau?' and in the journal Fourth International (August-September 1946 edition) under the heading 'Indo-China Assassinatioff of Ta Thu Thau"

Forty years have passed. We asked Prager what he thinks now of the issue and what he thinks of Ho Chi Minh's responsibility for this crime. He replied as follows:

Information *In July 1946 Ho Chi Minh held a press conference in a Paris hotel. He presented his policy on the integration of Indo-China into the French Union. I waited for him at the exit of the conference hall to have a discussion in which I introduced myself as a member of the PCI secretariat. 1 demanded in the name of the movement that he shed some light on the death of Ta Thu Thau which had deeply disturbed us. He replied that he deeply regretted his disappearance' because Ta Thu Thau had been 'an irreproachable revolutionary' . On the circumstance of his death he had no information because the situation was troubled and uncontrolable in the country.

"Certain information that came from Vietnam at the time revealed that members of the Viet-Minh were Ho Chi Minh organising murders of Trotskyists throughout Vietnam. But we lacked any direct information from the Indochinese Trotskyists with whom all contact had been lost. Lacking certain proof of the responsibility of the Stalinists in this affair we had several theories and proposed to the representatives of the Vier-Minh that they set up a commission of inquiry made up of representatives of the French and Indochinese workers' movement so as to shed some light on the issue. However all our efforts were in vain.

"In the following years the reports received from the Vietnamese Trotskyists and the information provided by those comrades who had succeeded in coming to Paris such as Luu Sanh Hanh, Trieu Son, Lang Tu Van etc., confirmed our fears and proved the responsibility of the Vietnamese Stalinists.

"We know now that the alleged authors of these executions, who are known, hold important posts in the Vietnamese Communist Party and the fact that these executions 1o0k place simultaneously throughout the country, shows clearly that it was a question of a concerted action which could have only been decided on by the insistence of the central body of the Party. These deeds have besides been accounted for in the official work The August Revolution' which appeared in Hanoi in 1960 in Vietnamese, and which quite naturally reproduced reports on the liquidation of Trotskyists in several provinces.

*ll seems very dangerous and implausible to personally absolve Ho Chi Minh from any responsibility for These crimes, given his campaign of denunciation against the Trotskyists who were portrayed as 'spies and criminals. In 1939 he was already talking of the necessity of politically exterminating' Trotskyists. From political extermination to actual extermination is only a short step."

The third discussion took place between Ho Chi Minh and Hoang Don Tri who was accompanied by his comrade Le Van. An engineer at the Central School in Paris, Hoang Don Tri is the brother of Hoang Don Van, Ta Thu Thau the former minister of labour in the provisional Viet-Minh government in 1945. He was one of the first intellectuals, with Tran Duc Thoo, Huang Xuan Man, etc., who formed the leadership of the 'General Delegation of Vietnamese in France' in Paris in 1944-45, and which was dissolved by the French government by decree on 19 October 1945 because it was fighting for the independence of Vietnam. Like Le Van, Hoang Don Tri gave up political activily several years ago and his statement bears polemical character.

*In 1946, at the time he came ANALYSISO why focus on the death of one single person? Why provoke discord and division among our struggling *Mr President, Ta Thu Thau was not one single person. He represented a political current, a concept of life and action for the people which interested many. His death in obscure circumstances has sown great doubt and suspicion. If your governmeni had nothing to do with this tragic death, it has every interest in shedding light on this affair. It will gain prestige and the people will be welded together all the more in the fight for freedom. Obscurity divides, not clari1y.

Sectarian

*The President: (Obviously used ro being applauded and approved, he seemed ill at ease faced with my 'insolent remarks. He took several drags from his cigarette). You are young and sectarian.

"No Mr President, we are not secmarian. The proof is that we initiated the formation of the General Delegalion of Vietnamese in France in September 1944, which grouped together all the Vietnamese in France. And it is in the interest of all Vietnamese that we are demanding The formation of a commission of inquiry with the suppert of your government, to find out who was responsible for the death of Ta Thu Thau and his comrades.

"The President without giving me a straight answer and without giving any promises in either direction just gave me a large apple."

----- pull-quotes -----

terror in Vietnam

VIETNAMIENNES CHRONIQUES

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 295

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →