Pandering to prejudice
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-12-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Bas Hardy reviews ''The the Militant in Liverpool"
Liverpool City Council's cheon engagement. Darkus Howe of certainly got the impression that hurry to get away had the interviewer alliance between the labour moveblinkered sectarian bahaviour of this report they can appreciate why many in the local black community any bus - derugulated or otherwise store — say Lewis's — in the city cenThe Liverpool City Council has less than 1% of its workforce who are simple refusal to admit the level of local capitalist state for their own sectarian organisational advantage. outraged the local black community. movement in the original (US) stake was set, not for the integration of the black community into the labour residential homes out of a total of is a semi-religious cryptosect which pushes a halfand of mutated Marxism, litics reactionary Socialist Organiser no 296 11 December 1986 page 5 başst eder tonesed hides ons been Terry Wogan!
Liverpool makes hold such a view. black. occupational structure, elections were either. 1,391"
shows:
Quality Excellent Average Poor The pat also tenı specific a (Tve got two minutes," said Derek Hatton, glancing at his fancy watch to calculate the time for his next lunBandung File' kept that remark in his TV report on race in Liverpool as an indication of Hatton's sensitivity and concern about black issues. One 'Degsey' would have been in less of a *The Racial Politics of Militant in because it shows how a mych needed ment and the black community was thrown away by the vicious and Militant. The left outside of Liverpool might like to debate whether or not Militant are racist, but reading Black people make up around 8% of Liverpool's population, but get on - and you will find no black bus drivers. Go into a big department tre, and try to count up the number of black staff on one hand, and you won't get past your first digit. Should you look along the back entry on the day your bıns get emptied. then you'll see plenty of black bin-liners. but no black bin men (or women).
Ghettos
In London there are plenty of black bus drivers, shop workers and refuse collectors, because whites aren't prepared to do these jobs. The economic situation in Liverpool means that blacks are excluded even from these "job Ghettos' The report states that the long established Liverpool community a community that has been without work for generations and that as a result of overt and institutionalised racism has hardly been able to penetrate any layers within the local *This has been reflected in the significant absence of black people from positions of responsibility in the labour movement. In broad terms, the trade union movement has historically colluded in third class economic status assigned to the black community, from their earlier efforts to undermine the position of black sea-men and to prevent black people working on public transport.
It must also be noted that none of Labour's 52 labour councillors are black. and none of the candidates Labour stood in the 1986 council Discrimination extends further into social welfare and housing provision. According to a Social Services Department report "There were only 7 black elders in a total of 1143 units of accommodation for elderly people: and in Liverpool 8, there were only 9 black people receiving meals on wheels out of a total of 4,553, 6 black people out of 1.038 in day care facilities, and 8 black people in City housing allocations a pattern of institutionalis as this table on the quality white 38.0% 20.0% 24.7% 17.3% if hot confine the C also show ed racism, of lettings black 19.6% 24.7% 38.2% 17.6% allocati ks with especia the Granby, Falkner Street area where 52.8% of all blacks were allocated housing. Another reason for the 'ghettoisation lies in the danger of attack from groups of 'poor white racist should blacks move into their areas areas.
Liverpool blacks were thus politically and socially marginalised group at the time Labour assumed majority control of the City Council in 1983. Positive action was needed to reverse discrimination and offer blacks a central role in the labour movement. The workerist' politics of Militant and its allies, however, led to the exact opposite.
Signs of this could be seen early on in the attitude of Tony Byrne, Housing and Finance supremo. (Now leader of the Council after last month's putsch ousted John Hamilton) Byrne opposed a motion to provide accommodation for elderly Chinese on the grounds that hostels for the elderly should be provided to meet the needs of the local community as a whole and not for any particular ethnic group." The Chinese community - arguably the most isolated and ignored of all the ethnic groups therefore went without!
The general line of the Militant is that there is 'no difference' berween black and white workers because both are exploited by capitalism. Attempts at positive action are bad because they "divide the working class" • Showing 'favouritism"" to blacks merely gives ammunition to harassment are really trying • to "jump the queue" for council accommodation.
The whole problem with this approach is that it totally ignores racism and more to the point, ends up pandering to latent racist prejudices in the white labour movement. Saying, as Byrne does, that blacks are no more oppressed than poor whites, is a racial harassment and violence black people are subjected to in our society.
Despite Militant's claim to be thodox Trotskyists', their attitude on the race question is the exact oposite of the one held by rotsky himselt, and his American co-thinkel James P Cannon.
Inaction
In the 1920's Cannon found that many white socialists in the USA thought that the oppression of blacks was purely and simply "an economic problem, part of the struggle between the workers and capitalists; nothing could be done about the special problems of discrimination and inequality this side of socialism." In Cannon's opinion this was nothing more than a formula for inaction on the Negro front, and - incidentally - a convenient shield for the dormant racial prejudices of white radicals themselves Trotsky talked of the need to bring blacks into the centre of the labour 'Militant' newspaper_in 1929. We must find the road to the most deprived. beginning with the Negro, whom capitalist society has converted into a pariah, and who must learn to see in us his revolutionary brothers."
(The way our present, pale imitation copy 'Militants'" do this is to exclude blacks trom DLP aggregate meetings on technical grounds which they don t apply to white party members, and putting barriers in the way of blacks Militant Stalinist baked bı racial politics are wishing to join the Labour Party if they happen to disagree with the Militant line on race).
Trotsky saw the major task for anti-racists to be an uncompromising struggle against racism in the white working class. "The negro can be developed to a class standpoint only when the white worker is educated 99.9% of the American workers are chauvinists, in relation to the Negroes they аге hangmen and they are so also to the Chinese:
Trotsky even argued that white workers should support the right of blacks to set up their own state in America - a policy guaranteed to nake Hatton, Byrne and co. choke or their after-hours pints in the Vernon Arms!
The Liverpool Militant leadership old a position on independent blac struggle which is closer to that of Judge Roy Bean than to JP Cannon.
They refuse to conduct a political and ideological struggle against racism in the trade unions and then go on to expect the black community to unite lich people whe have tavetionally col with the employers to deny blacks equal job opportunities. But what if blacks refuse to accept the subordinate place assigned to them in Militant's scenario for socialism? If existing black spokespersons don't prove to be compliant then it is necessary to import them!
The black caucus had been pushing for many months for the appointment of various equal opportunities officers who would implement positive prorammes of action to combat racism ut they had not bargained for insider dealing . The City Council went on to advertise for seven posts in a Central Race Relations Unit.
Needs Unfortunately, these post: designed to be filled by appli would retlect the aspirations of ethnic communities in They had to be filled by individuals to compere with women's groups and who would unquestioningly toe the the disabled for five places on the new line of the Militant-dominated council ¡Equal Opportunities Committee. ' All leadership. three of these groups refused to lend The Bond appointment was so themselves to such a charade blatantly rigged that even someone Everyone on the non-Militant left with the brains of a rocking horse could knows that 95% plus of what is said in see through the charade. Bond had ob- the Black Caucus report is factually viously been chosen at short notice by true, as are most of the criticisms the Militant, who were desperate to made. The whole thing is a damning find 'their own' black candidate, given indictment to Militant, and honest the fact that their political line did not supporters of the Tendency must surely lend itself to the mass recruitment of hang their heads in shame if they black people. bother to read it.
Bond's appointment, carried out by The report was written by Gideon the 'fixers' who were manipulating the Ben-Tovim - ex Eurocommunist and low supporter of the pro-Kinnockite Iverpool Labour Left clique. As such.
Ben-Tovim glosses up the role of his local Labour Parties, and trade unions. mates lan Williams and Dave Leach. But Militant had not yet ejected their Yet for most of the time the race confull sack of poison. The order went out itoversy raged these individuals kept 'Defend Bond at all costs!" - even if their heads down this meant employing racist stereotypes to do so Courage The black caucus was accused of being 'unrepresentative of the local Ben-Tovim also fails to mention that black community. A glance at the list SO supporter Kevin Feintuck and of supporting organisations is enough Granby ward activist Sam Semoff were to disprove this. It was also felt by Mili- the only two party members with Tant that "black careerists' coveted courage enough to speak out against Bond's job. Are careers open only to Militant at the municipal policy conwhite people? Is not Sampson Bond a ference. Leach and Williams were very able careerist given his obvious silent on this occasion. Their boldness lack of qualifications for the job he was only increased with the pace of the appointed for? NEC's attack on the local party.
Militant is a semi-religious cryptoConflict Stalinist sect which pushes a half-baked brand of mutated Marxism. Despite With the appointment of Bond, the the subjective anti-racism of many of its supporters, its racial politics — and many other aspects of its politics and movement, but conflict with it. practice — are reactionary. Its general Militant's attempt to substitute itselt performance in Liverpool has alienated tor the black community proved an ab- broad support for the struggle against ject failure, despite the fact that they the Tories and played into the hands of put five full-time workers into the Pro-capitalist clements in the Labour Granby ward. MAG (Merseyside action were not soon published a document which was Group, set up as Bond's minders') damaging period of Town Hall Pol If the left is to recover from this ants ad n eds itself critical of the council's employ- Pot-ism it must face up to the many Iverp sol. three main local black recruits to MAG ment record. Shortly afterwards the negative things Militant has done. To blindly defend self-proclaimed leftleft in disgust at the way they had been wingers whose actions reinforce divimanipulated sions in our class is a recipe for disaster:
Whilst the phoney front was being Let us hope that we can pick up the floated, the real representatives of the pieces before it is too late. black community were turted out of the lown Hall when the Race Relations The Racial Politics of Militant in LiverLiaison Committee was abolished. pool is available from Source Books, 3 From 12 delegates on the old commit- Myrtle Parade, Liverpool, L7 7EL. Price ree, the black caucus was now expected ฿.95
Scan page 6
a storv of